Friday, April 21, 2017

ElumTools Presentation today for the University of Northern Iowa

I am excited to be doing a presentation on lighting analysis for Gowri Betrabet Gulwadi's Interior Design students today at the University of Northern Iowa! I will be presenting remotely from home.

The Building Systems and Lighting class will learn how ElumTools can be used within Autodesk Revit to derive point-by-point illuminance calculations. This involves properly developed lighting fixture families, surface reflectances defined by Revit's materials or overridden by ElumTools and properly enclosed spaces.

ElumTools Ribbon tab in Revit

  • Note to self, resist clicking the Update button just before a presentation!

As I mentioned in a previous post, BILT 2017 Speaking Engagements, I will be doing a class in Toronto just on lighting fixture families later this year. Today, I will mainly be talking about the generic content provided with ElumTools.

My Interior Design for Autodesk Revit 2017 book has an appendix covering the use of ElumTools. The developers, Lighting Analysts, Inc., offer students free access to ElumTools. This must be requested by an instructor.

Having some specialized experience like this is great on a resume and in a portfolio! At a recent IES meeting I met a graduate from the University of Minnesota's Interior Design program who is exclusively doing lighting design at a large firm in Minneapolis.

Fun stuff!

Autodesk Insight 360 - Walls; Part 2

Following yesterday's discussion, Autodesk Insight 360 - Walls; Part 1, on how Revit determines analytical walls from mass elements, I will now shift our attention from mass elements to wall elements.

As seen in the first image below, I created the same "award-wining design" in this post, based on the massing in the previous installment, Notice that this more developed design has parapets, which are defined by a single wall extending from Level 1 up a certain distance above the roof plane.

Revit model created with wall, floor and a roof elements.
When the Energy Analytical Model (EAM) is created in Revit, we see similar results when compared to the previous massing exercise. We have Exterior Walls and Underground Walls.


Exterior Walls element selected in the EAM


Underground Walls element selected in the EAM
If you are paying close attention and comparing the wall area numbers with the previous post you may have noticed the area for the same exterior wall is not quite the same. The reason is that the parapets are automatically omitted from the "exterior walls" equation. The image below shows the EAM has converted the parapet walls to Shade surfaces. This is perfect!

  • It is not as accurate to simply take the literal wall, floor and roof areas and plug them into an equation.


Shading element selected in the EAM
BTW, we can control the visibility of the various parts of the EAM from the Visibility/Graphics Overrides dialog as seen in the image below. This is what I did to create the the images above.

Visibility/Graphics Override dialog for 3D Energy Model view
Once we push this "Revit Elements" based model to Insight we understand this more detailed design iteration results in a more accurate Cost/EUI. It is interesting to see that the super simple thermally zoned mass analysis,from the previous post, offered reasonable close preliminary information.

Walls-based model and Mass-based model in Insight
Setting the Mass Exterior Wall construction to uninsulated also applies to Revit's wall elements. This may be a little confusing since the word "Mass" is in the name of the parameter you are adjusting. When pushed out to Insight, we see the "BIM Setting" is properly positioned at uninsulated for the Wall Construction input.

Insight 'BIM setting' aligns with Revit setting

Like yesterday, I went in and applied an override in the Schematic Types dialog (within the Energy Settings dialog) and selected an R38 construction. When we subsequently push a model to Insight there is something important to understand... the EAM is totally static geometrically and in terms of information. So, if we don't delete and recreate the EAM this new change would not influence the analysis.

When pushing the model to Insight, we are conveniently prompted to automatically recreate the EAM as shown in the image below. However, I think it is best to do it manually and visually inspect it for any irregularities; for example, someone decided to model all the wall types just outside the building.

Insight export prompt within Revit
After deleting and recreating the EAM we get the expected results in Insight!

Insight 'BIM setting' aligns with revised Revit setting
This workflow represents a simple yet powerful opportunity to enhance the performance of most any project being developed in Revit. Like any tool, taking the time to understand it's various parts is key to getting accurate results. Continuing the focus on walls, in future posts, I will talk about using Revit materials to define the thermal properties in a wall, and then another post will look at some things to keep in mind when it comes to Window to Wall Ratio (WWR). So stay tuned for more...

Thursday, April 20, 2017

Autodesk Insight 360 - Walls; Part 1

Autodesk Insight 360 is a powerful energy modeling tool in conjunction with a Revit model. To help realize it's full potential, I thought I would offer up a series of short posts which focus on specific elements of Revit, Insight and energy modeling. You may be surprised at how simple, yet powerful, this feature set can be!

I plan on writing a few short posts to cover just walls in the content of energy modeling. I will start with these three topics:
  • Massing
  • Revit walls
  • Window to Wall Ratio (WWR)
For this post, I want to highlight how Revit defines exterior wall construction, from mass elements, when generating the Energy Analytical Model (EAM).

We can perform an energy analysis against simple Revit massing. In the images below I created a super simple mass. This mass extends below level 1 to define a basement area. I selected the mass and used the Mass Floors button on the Ribbon to specify Basement and Level 1 for this specific element.
  • FYI: If I did not specify Mass Floors, the entire element would be seen as a shade surface. This is helpful when representing adjacent buildings.
Before we get to Insight we need to create an EAM in Revit. There is a lot of cool stuff happening here. For now, given our "wall" focus, we will notice from the next two images that the EAM understands above grade and below grade walls. In the next post we will see it even understands parapet walls when using Revit elements (i.e. not massing).

EAM with an exterior wall selected

EAM with below grade wall selected
The thermal properties of a wall are defined in the Energy Settings dialog. In the Other Options sub-dialog, there are three successive options; Conceptual Types, Schematic Types and Detailed Elements. By default, Revit uses the Conceptual Types settings as we will see...

The image below shows an extreme example of no insulation so it is super clear what is happening when we get into Insight. Notice, this is set in Conceptual Types.

Exterior walls set to uninsulated in Conceptual Types
When we get to Insight we see the "BIM setting" (triangle symbol) for wall construction is aligned with the uninsulated end of the spectrum per our selection within Revit.
  • FYI: I used to think the "BIM setting" replaced the input it aligned with on the Cost Range slider, but as you can see below it is just positioned along side it; notice Uninsulated is still a separate option even though it is the same value as the "BIM setting".

Wall construction result in Insight

If we apply an override in Schematic Types, this takes precedent over the Conceptual Types setting... but just for the categories selected. In the example below, only walls are overriding the Conceptual Types settings. Here I go towards the other end of the spectrum with an R38 wall construction.

Wall value override selected in Schematic Types
Back in Insight we see the "BIM Setting" has moved accordingly.

Wall construction result in Insight
The Conceptual Types options are somewhat limited, Schematic Types have a lot more options, and when we get to using Revit materials to define thermal properties there is no limit to the number of options we could have (as we will see in a later post).

I was working with one of our architects this week and she noticed that Schematic Types even has a Straw Bale option as seen in the image below!

Straw bale wall construction option within Schematic Types
The great thing about Insight is we can dynamically modify these inputs apart from the Revit model. However, this information is helpful to understand so you can set some baseline inputs, e.g. based on your state's energy code or ASHRAE 90.1, within your template. And, as the project progresses and decisions are made, those decisions can be captured within the BIM.

Stay tuned for more...


Wednesday, April 19, 2017

Life of an Architect's Playhouse Competition; My Submission

Life of and Architect (LoaA) is a great, and humorous, blog dedicated to advocating for our profession. Each year Bob Borson, creator of LoaA, hosts a Playhouse Design Competition to support Dallas CASA, which serves as voices in court for abused and neglected children. What's not to love about this... design for a cause that helps kids! Even if I did not make the cut.

This year I submitted a design which, as I just said, did not make the final cut, so I thought I would share my failed attempt here... and follow with a discussion on how 100% of this effort was done within the Revit 2018 beta - for fun:)

My design idea stemmed from my families hobby, which is urban chicken keeping. We have egg laying chickens in our backyard, which is within the city limits. The image below is our modest coop and outdoor run which is connected to a 16 foot square garden. In the middle-right of the photo you can see a door from the run into the garden.


Also, notice in the iamge above, the light fixture I wrote about yesterday. Oh, and the main section of the coop is the mostly-enact remains of a large chandelier shipping box for the hotel my father-in-law works for.

Here is my design, speaks for itself... mostly.

Considering one of Bob's recent posts, I guess all the glass should be screening so the kids don't melt in Texas. Here in northern Minnesota we literally still have traces of snow in mid-April! So the windows for the kids and chickens made sense at the time!

This image is printed directly from a Revit sheet. Nothing was exported or imported. Other than Revit itself, I used ArchVision's Dashboard add-in for Revit in order to place the entourage (RPC content).

Everything here was done within the beta version of Revit 2018. I have been active in the AutoCAD and Revit beta programs for years. I find the best way to test software is to do real stuff in it. Randomly picking buttons and running commands does not adequately test the software.

So, even though I did not make the cut, I had fun working on this while, at the same time, beta testing the latest version of Revit. And, as I mentioned, this is for a great cause so I wanted to highlight that as well!

You should consider entering a submission next year. being one of the 27 finalists out of 1,100 submissions would be great, but supporting a good cause is even better!


Tuesday, April 18, 2017

Revit Scale Command: Its origin and limitations

Did you know Revit did not always have a Scale command! For the first several years, there was literally no way to scale anything. We had Mirror, Copy, Rotate, but no Scale command. I think the logic stemmed from the idea that you would never scale building elements/components. For example, if a door or window were scaled, it should not get thicker or the hardware would not change size.

Here is an old AUGI fourm post, from 2003, showing an experienced AutoCAD user asking about the lack of a scale command in Revit: http://forums.augi.com/showthread.php?905-Scale-command

Even with the Scale command, there are some things that are still not able to be scaled. The above logic still applies... you cannot scale doors, windows, most families, etc. BTW, this command was originally called Resize; the keyboard shortcut still being RE.


From Revit help: "The Scale tool is available for lines, walls, images, DWG and DXF imports, reference planes, and position of dimensions. You can scale elements graphically or numerically."

I was recently using the beta version of Revit 2018 to develop a design for a competition, which I will talk more about in another post, and ran across a family I needed to scale down. To save time, I found this family online (don't remember where), but it was way too big (notice the 2'-2" dimension).


Luckily there is a trick to scale down any family... load the family into a Planting family and then load that family into another Planting family. Now the family has a built-in Type parameter called Height which scales the entire family up or down (this is normally used to change the height of a tree so they are not all the same).


Here is the family at the correct scale in the project...


And a 3D view to show more of the detail I did not want to model for a competition.


The light source in the original family still provided light when rendered!

I first learned about the great trick to scale an entire family from Marcello Sgambelluri. who is a top rated speaker at Autodesk University and BiLT (formerly RTC). We first met at RTC (Revit Technology Conference) in Stone Mountain Georgia in 2012 - we both had our families there. Check out his AU session on this topic here: AB3020: Size Does Matter: Learn How to Scale and Morp Families in Revit. He also has a great blog podcast, Simply Complex, which I will be on someday when our schedules align!

Monday, April 17, 2017

RSMeans; A lost Revit feature

RSMeans is a widely used cost estimating resource in the USA. Up until about Revit 8 (2005) there was an RSMeans module built in, as seen in the next several images... they pretty much speak for themselves.







Sunday, April 16, 2017

Revit's Beyond Line Style

Revit has a few built-in Line Styles which cannot be renamed or deleted. A few of these lines can be seen in the first image below, and are named like this: <built-in line style name>. The Beyond style is interesting in that it automatically replaces other lines, in a given plan view, when certain conditions apply.


To see how this works, let's say we want to make all our footings dashed in our structural foundation plan; by default, all these elements are shown with continuous lines as shown in the next image. FYI: There are other ways to achieve this result, such as view filters, but that is not the point.


The Beyond line style appears automatically in a plan view when an element, any element, exists between the view's Bottom and View Depth settings as seen in the View Range dialog below.


The section below highlights this range, for our example, between the Bottom and View Depth. The footing has a fairly wide range it can exist in and still be automatically dashed in our plan view. This would account for any stepping and/or grade change.


The result is all the strip footings and isolated footings are shown dashed in this specific view as shown below. Of course, things turned off in this view are not affected, nor are other views as they have their own View Range settings.


The Beyond Line Style is set at the project level from the Manage tab (Manage > Additional Settings > Line Styles). This Line Style can be overridden per view in the Visibility/Graphics Override dialog (Model tab > Lines).

This opportunity is not readily apparent in a new project as the Beyond line style is set to continuous in the Revit-provided templates and most plan views start with the Bottom and View Depth set at the same value--which would mean the Beyond line style could never appear in that view.

This example, and more like it, can be found in Design Integration using Autodesk Revit 2018.