I was having a discussion the other day about
Bentley software we use and asked why we use a particular program when we have access to as similar software within our
Autodesk subscription. I was reminded that the "included" Autodesk software,
Autodesk Storm and Sanitary, has calculation errors.
What Is Autodesk Storm and Sanitary Analysis?
I then remembered submitting a support ticket directly to Autodesk Support about
two years ago. Unfortunately this serious design flaw has yet to be rectified and thus we are using, and paying for, competing software. I thought I would share this so anyone who uses this software would be aware of the issue if depending on it as a design tool.
Here is what I submitted in March of 2016:
"The spread calculation for Storm and Sanitary Analysis is not calculating property. As you can see from the attached SPF file, the calculation works for gutter slopes of 2%, however for slopes greater than 2% the program calculates a number under the actual value and for slopes under 2% it calculates a value over the actual value."
The two images below where submitted with the support ticket to depict how we did a manual...